Recently, I was the beneficiary of a special physics teaching award (thank you, you are very kind). Apart from the standing ovations and the visits with prime ministers and other dignitaries from around the world (I may be exaggerating), I was also given a $1000 educational grant to be used to further my development as a physics teacher.
For days on end, I racked my brains as to what I could use this money for. Certainly any kind of biking equipment, as attractive as they might seem and as helpful as they would be for my own personal development, could not be considered as proper choices for purchases – unless, of course, the bike parts were made to be part of some elaborate mechanical device that would illustrate important principles of physics to my students. An intriguing idea. Some kind of Rube Goldberg device?
In the end, I decided that it would be most beneficial for me to get myself a quality iPad. Sure, this device has excellent personal uses, but in the spirit of the award, I could also use it to create quality physics educational videos, especially with the magical PencilPro. When I suggested this to the representative, she was quite hesitant at first and needed to discuss this with the other big people in the organization (whoever they might be). But after some explanations about its honourable physics-based purposes, with some demonstrations of its capabilities to advance the education of students around the world, they were entirely on board. All I had to do was go and buy it, and once done, then I could send the receipt to them and they would reimburse me.
I did my share of research for a few weeks, making sure I knew exactly which version of an iPad I wanted (the Air, if you are interested) and which accessories I would need (such as the PencilPro). I had all my information ready, and all my ducks in a row. I just had to wait for a convenient day to make the trip. In other words, I had to ask my wife when she would be willing to drive me there.
And it turned out that today was the day. We decided to make a date out of it. We would go the mall, get my iPad, etc. and a few other items, and then we would go to have lunch at MKT, which would be paid for by a gift card from a generous student and her family. (Thank you so much, by the way. The chili dog was amazing!)
I knew that teachers get a special discount at Apple when purchasing items, and so, we made sure that I had clear teacher ID – in fact, I brought 3 different cards, providing irrefutable evidence. I was not about to let this opportunity to save pass me by.
When we got to the Apple store, it was already pretty busy, despite being midweek and in the morning. But we got one of their geniuses (do they still call them that?) after waiting only for a few minutes, enough time to spot the iPad I wanted and verify that it was the perfect one for me.
When the genius starting talking to us, my wife very quickly asked about the teacher discount. While doing so, she was fishing through her beautiful Gucci bag to get my three types of teacher identification. But the agent told us that such ID was not necessary. Instead, there was an app that they now used to verify my teacher status, and the store used this method instead.
Now I knew all about this app, since I had read up on it, and in fact, I had already used it during the previous week just to make sure that it would recognize that I was an active teacher and thus qualified for the rebate. But I was under the impression that this was only needed if you were doing an online purchase. I was convinced that when you were physically in the store, then physical evidence … such as ID … would be used instead. It only stood to reason. But reason was not winning out on t his day. She refused to look at my ID, and instead, required me to go through the app. Genius, indeed!
This proved to be a serious problem. I do not happen to own a phone, and this process required me to have one. We tried to use my wife’s phone instead, but I did not have my personal gmail on her phone, and in order to set it up there, I had to remember my password for that account. The last time I used that password was months, if not years ago, and so there was no chance in hell that this old brain of mine was going t o remember it on the spot, especially with both of them looking upon me expectantly.
There was nothing the genius could do, and I felt the rage building up within me. I felt betrayed because I could not receive this discount only because I did not own a phone. I suddenly became convinced that the world had secretly (or blatantly?) conspired to require all of its citizens to own a cellphone. And, when someone doesn’t have one, they have to go through countless other hoops to receive something that people with phones could get with one click (or qr code scan).
The genius looked upon me with sadness. I was not sure if this look arose because she felt bad that she could not offer me the rebate, or simply just because I did not have a phone. I felt like a second-class citizen. I was afraid that she was going to give me some kind of handout or donation to get me through the day. It was humliliating.
Alas, we bit the bullet hard and decided to drive all the way home to get the required information and to set up my wife’s phone so that it would show that I was a teacher. Then she returned to the Apple store about an hour later. A huge waste of time, but fortunately, we were not in a rush and could afford the lost time. And really, it was a beautiful day, with a bright blue sky and nice warm temperatures. Hard to be angry on such a day.
We returned with the information and we got a brand new genius. My wife explained what had happened, and in her explanation, she told this person that it was all because I did not have a phone. He thought she meant that I had forgotten to bring it with me, but when she further explained that I did not own one at all, he turned to me and said, “Good for you!”
Really? Was it good for me? I mean, it certainly wasn’t a good thing when we had to drive an additional hour to get this app information, especially when we would have done it all immediately if I had my own phone.
So why did he think it was good? Especially since he worked at a technology store where everyone had a phone and used it regularly, in their own lives and in their occupation.
I thought about this for a while, because it was not the first time I had someone say this to me. And what I have arrived at is that people see my phoneless life much like they would perceive someone who did a solo walk across the Antarctic or who free soloed up a rock face in Yosemite. It is fascinating that someone can do such a thing, and one can even imagine how it could be considered heroic or majestic, but there is no way in hell that they would do the same thing! The sacrifice, the risk, the diminished lifestyle, it would be just too much of a sacrifice.
So is it good or bad to be without a phone? I will leave it up to the reader to answer this. And when you figure out what your answer is, don’t bother calling me. (I don’t have a phone.)
[Interestingly, I wrote this blog using my new iPad Air with the attached keyboard. The number of typos I made for this one blog approached something astronomical, making me feel like I had never used a keyboard before. In fact, this blog took me just as much time to edit as it did to write. The jury is out. I may just have to return the keyboard and stick with my tried and true keyboard from my desktop.]